G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero - The Dreaded 6" Discussion [Archive] - YoJoe.com Forums

View Full Version : G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero - The Dreaded 6" Discussion

10-23-2014, 10:11 PM
If you’ve been perusing the online G.I. Joe community this week, you’ve no doubt seen mention of the possibility that there are some whispers of 6” scale G.I. Joe figures drifting in the winds. Heck, the 2015 San Diego ComicCon was even mentioned as a kick off point for these figures.

Is it true? Nobody knows at this point… but whether or not it is true, it does bring up some valuable discussion points.

I’ve received a lot of personal messages asking what I think about the whole thing (as if my opinion matters more than anyone elses). And, as usual, I can see both sides.

My first instinct is that G.I. Joe should try and focus on being the best toy it can be at one scale before it starts spiraling off into other scales. Over the past 50 years we’ve seen many different styles, formats, and figure scales, but things always seem to fall back to the old standby 12” and 4”, with 4” obviously being the dominant force in recent years. Well… dominant in relative terms at least.

So with 50 years of market data telling Hasbro that G.I. Joe is most successful at those two scales, why muddy the waters and introduce yet another scale and format to even further divide the fandom?

One might argue that G.I. Joe is having trouble finding a retail foothold at the $8 price point with 4” figures, even backed by a $400million film. Will $20 6” figures do anything to further the lifespan of the brand? Emphatically I say no.

But that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a entirely bad idea all together.

Perhaps G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero could use a little spark, right? Perhaps, instead of wondering why Hasbro is trying to spread thin a brand that already is watered down, we need to consider the fact that since G.I. Joe isn’t a behemoth, maybe this is the time to start something new?

My only concern is that Hasbro at this point seems to be treating G.I. Joe as a short term prospect. Most toylines are short term prospects these days, but each assortment of these 4” figures is so specifically geared for a short term theme that you wonder if there are any long term plans. In recent years, G.I. Joe has obviously become a film-based toyline, with some cost-savings filler figures to fit in those gaps when movies aren’t in the theaters. I don’t see a 6” line changing that. I think we all know that the 6” line will simply revisit the vintage look at a larger (and more detailed) scale. In some instances I think that could be fun, and I think (again) short term that will provide some spark. But it’s a finite spark with a clear beginning and end. Unlike Star Wars there aren’t thousands of diehards who’ve been waiting 30 years for a 6” Ponda Baba. As soon as G.I. Joe starts dipping into 3rd tier characters (which will happen far sooner than many folks admit, I think) the 6” line will be on thin ice, and we’ll once again be faced with the whole “what’s next” approach?

G.I. Joe needs some serious revitalization. It needs some kind of Beast Wars, Sigma 6, or dare I say it, G.I. Joe: Renegades level support and effort (only maybe without friggen killing the landmark animated series before it even aired this time). A toyline can only survive on the regurgitated designs from 30 years ago for so long, and we’re reaching a breaking point.

Transformers has survived and excelled because it has successfully reinvigorated itself on a consistent basis throughout the past 30 years. Beast Wars led to Robots in Disguise, led to Armada, led to Classics, led to Generations, which has been further supplemented by fantastic comic books that Hasbro is actually using as inspiration for more toys, not to mention video games (yes I’m forgetting the films on purpose).

G.I. Joe has had one clear behemoth success, and it was three decades ago. Eventually we need to stop looking back and start looking forward, or the brand will always be taking things one year at a time, with no clear direction. While 6” figures might be a fun distraction and a quick spark, if Hasbro is serious about making G.I. Joe a player again, they must realize that’s not the solution to their problem.

G.I. Joe needs synergy. The same synergy that has worked so well for Transformers over the past few years, films notwithstanding. Get an animated series rolling, develop a video game with CARE, PRECISION and continuity. Embrace the comics! For the love of God, don’t be afraid to take some chances and put some resources behind it and maybe, just maybe give the thing half a chance to succeed or fail before you pull the plug. You might just be surprised as the results.

Image courtesy D & D Customs and HissTank (http://www.hisstank.com/gi-joe-news/customs-10/destro-enemy-weapons-supplier-6-inch-scale-custom-12151/)

10-24-2014, 12:05 AM
I agree with your analysis of the idea of a 6" move. The last two paragraphs, I think, summed up the real issues.

I am no expert, but it seems to me that G. I. Joe is a nostalgia act right now. That's not entirely a bad thing. People my age are now looking back to their favorite childhood properties and demanding big budget movies for them. Another movie and more cartoons may help sell the umpteenth version of Snake Eyes. But if G. I. Joe is going to survive to the next generation it has to move beyond nostalgia. It can't forever be an adaptation of an 80s-era military line. Our kids are not growing up in that world. As weird as it may be to imagine, the G. I. Joe our kids feel nostalgic about 30 years from now may not have Snake Eyes in it.

I think Kirk Bozigian has said, when it comes to the future of G. I. Joe, "blow it up." That may be somewhat extreme, but probably not too far off the mark. Instead of reimagining Snakes Eyes and Duke, there needs to be a new G. I. Joe that will excite the imagination of kids the way our G. I. Joe excited us 30 years ago. It may look very different from what we're used to. It may seem as alien to us as the 3 3/4 inch Joes seemed to the 12" collectors. The scale isn't the important thing. There's nothing magical about 4 inches (ahem), or 6 inches, or whatever. The magic is in the innovation, the creativity, and the courage to take the risk of making a new generation of G. I. Joe that is entirely directed at our children, not remakes of daddy's old toys.

Maybe it's not impossible. G. I. Joe: Retaliation had the courage to literally blow up most of the team, and even kill (hopefully) Duke. I never thought I would see that in a G. I. Joe movie. Maybe the the creative spark is already there, waiting to be given its chance. I dunno. I'm just a schmuck on a message board.